Both went to the student health clinic for gynecological care and both ended up in an exam room with Dr. George Tyndall. Both later said they were sexually assaulted by the doctor, and struggled for years afterward to trust men and medical professionals. When it came time for USC to compensate them for their injuries, however, their stories diverged sharply.
Behind the jaw-dropping s, however, lies a lopsided economic landscape that has left some exuberant and others feeling bruised and cheated. It is the result of a novel approach USC and its lawyers took to compensate alumnae treated by the gynecologist. A year and a half ago, those former patients had to make a choice between two legal pathways. All were eligible for a federal class-action settlement promoted by USC and several law firms, but they could opt out of the class settlement and gamble on individual lawsuits in state Superior Court.
Would you like to meet for coffee
More than women pursued the second option. It is now clear that from a strictly financial perspective, these risk takers fared ificantly better. Plaintiffs routinely collect different amounts from the same organization for similar injuries, but experts said the difference in the two groups of Tyndall patients was unusual and surprising.
In that case, there were disparities too, but much smaller. In the USC cases, some angry class-action participants are now consulting attorneys about potential legal malpractice claims. Most spoke on the condition of anonymity. I think they deserved that. I just think we also deserve that.
A similar dynamic could play out at UCLA. James Heaps, an obstetrician and gynecologist accused of assaulting and harassing patients. USC was inundated with lawsuits after revelations in that Tyndall, the sole full-time gynecologist at the campus clinichad been kept on staff despite complaints.
Sex abuse scandals have proved a reputational and financial nightmare for organizations like the Catholic Church and Boy Scouts of America. Within weeks of the first Tyndall lawsuit, the Quinn Emanuel lawyers approached attorneys who had filed cases in federal court in hopes of reaching a deal. These law firms, including San Francisco-based Lieff Cabraser and Seattle-based Hagens Berman, entered into secret negotiations with USC on behalf of not just the clients they had ed up, but all the women who received gynecologic care from Tyndall between and At the time of the negotiations, prominent universities were paying much larger amounts to sexual abuse victims than provided for under the class action.
The university let him continue treating students. The majority would have likely never sued, but wrapping them into the settlement guaranteed they never could. Wilson approved the settlement. Chi, the healthcare IT professional, had been a client of Hagens Berman, but she said she had misgivings about the firm even before negotiations started.
Hagens Berman partner Steve Berman responded that Chi received a copy of the lawsuit before it was filed and the document clearly indicated she was the only plaintiff. Secret USC records reveal dire warnings about gynecologist accused of abusing students.
For usc women, largest-ever sex abuse payout leaves bitterness, vast disparities
Confidential records released this week show decades of warnings to the University of Southern California about Dr. All former patients were enrolled automatically in the class-action settlement, but anyone could opt out and press a lawsuit in state court. This dynamic created a schism with the university and the class-action lawyers on one side and attorneys ready to pursue state court lawsuits on the other. Those state court attorneys, caught off guard by the class-action settlement, furiously attacked it as a USC cover-up that would shortchange victims.
Unlike in individual lawsuits, the settlement was completely private. No one would have to testify in open court. The settlement also offered the certainty of a financial award, with different tiers of payments depending on how much each woman wanted to participate. On the other hand, if the women sued, there was no guarantee of money.
Their cases might be thrown out or rejected by juries.
Women had about a year to decide which route to choose. Her experience with Tyndall was unpleasant, she said, but had little long-term impact on her. Even after learning about the massive state court settlement, she said, she had no regrets. Those who now regret staying in the class-action offered various explanations for the decision they now second-guess.
She thought only a handful of women would take the step of filing suit, not the hundreds who ultimately did. Tyndall, I would have done that.
Another said she was unfamiliar with a proper gynecology exam and initially thought her experience was probably not bad enough to merit a suit. During the class-action interview, she began to understand how Tyndall had violated her. She rejected the idea that the class-action participants did not have enough information or legal acumen to choose wisely.
The state court cases against USC took just under three years to resolve. About 15 women were deposed as were USC administrators and one trustee. Though lawyers for the state court cases had criticized the lack of transparency in the class action, their settlement does not require USC to make public internal files or deposition In dania woman ng fuck it boys, which remain confidential. Some said their attorneys did not inform them of the law that temporarily lifted the statute of limitations for sex abuse cases so that people with dated claims could sue.
Leal and other attorneys are interviewing prospective clients about a potential legal malpractice claim against the class-action lawyers. She also said that USC alums were besieged with advertising by lawyers seeking to take on individual lawsuits after the statute of limitations changed. The Orange County mother said she had coped with trauma over Tyndall by focusing on what the eventual financial award would do for her young children. Matt Hamilton is a reporter for the Los Angeles Times. He won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative reporting with colleagues Harriet Ryan and Paul Pringle and was part of the team of reporters that won a Pulitzer Prize for its coverage of the San Bernardino terrorist attack.
Harriet Ryan is an investigative reporter for the Los Angeles Times. She is a graduate of Columbia University. County coronavirus spike hits alarming levels, with 10, infected in a week, as Delta variant spre. Diamonds, gold, luxury homes: Inside one L.
Williamstown festival crew walks off the job. All Sections. About Us. B2B Publishing. Business Visionaries.
Hot Property. Times Events.
Times Store. Facebook Twitter Show more sharing options Share Close extra sharing options. By Matt HamiltonHarriet Ryan. Attorney Steve Berman. California Secret USC records reveal dire warnings about gynecologist accused of abusing students.
George Tyndall in L. County Superior Court in July Matt Hamilton. Follow Us twitter instagram facebook.
Harriet Ryan. Subscribers Are Reading. California L. California Diamonds, gold, luxury homes: Inside one L.